HOME
PLAYLIST
THE QUIZ
COMMENTARY
LINKS
CONTACT
             
 
ARCHIVES
 

 

COMMENTARY >> RANTS

(DON’T) SHUT UP & PLAY THE MUSIC

Sick of being ignored by your favourite performer or band ? I’m not suggesting that you are a stalker, but perhaps you are a modern day concert-goer. Someone who’s bought the albums & now buys a seat to see their chosen musical heroes as they play either exactly like the record or utterly unlike it, both of which can be good, but between songs don’t talk to their audience! This is not a rehearsal in an empty hall, there are people paying rapt attention to every nuance & gesture, listening intently & yet the stage patter is often non existent or mumbled, surely they could have anticipated the situation & thought of something to say by now! Are they incapable or just rude?

Imagine if we sat silent between numbers, no applause or whistles or simply mumbled amongst ourselves & ignoring them! Years ago Van Morrison was canned for his Melbourne concert because he did not say a word to the audience (& turned his back on them for most of the time) & Neil Young who also played the same week opened his concert with the faecetious “ They canned Van for playing music & not talking, so tonight we’re gonna talk & not play music!” But surely something in between is not too much to ask. Our esteemed editor in last month’s missive mentioned that Bob Dylan on his never ending tour does not say anything to the awaiting throng, making you wonder if he is really so phobic about being a spokesman for anything that he dare not even speak. Mind you he rarely even speaks to his band, years ago after a show at the Palais one of his stunned band members was seen wandering around muttering "He spoke to me" as if the sky had opened up. And this was half way through a world tour!

Even The Beatles & The Rolling Stones back when they were powering through 25 minute sets that would put The Ramones to shame still managed to engage with the audience with a quip or 2, at least letting us know that they knew which town or country they were in & who the hell they were playing to. Mind you that can have it’s pitfalls, you can come across as a “Yo Cleveland! ” Spinal Tap cliché or as happened when a Festival Hall of B Boys & B Girls turned from a rap along horde to a booing & abusive beast when Public Enemy’s Flavor Flav yelled “ Yo Sydney! “ He may have known what time it was, just not where he was.

But at least they made an effort. Most of these people are intensely ambitious, it’s taken years of radio & TV appearances, interviews, magazine articles, meet & greets & photographic sessions to get to this point & now they’re suddenly shy & “aw shucks” incoherent? Surely someone would have pointed out to them by now that a concert was not just about the music, that it was also about performance & that that might require one or 2 words in an hour or so. Jackson Browne, Bruce Springsteen, Richard Thompson & a few others manage to include the audience into the performance, Browne in particular on his recent acoustic tour was more than happy to chat to the audience about his songs & even play oddball requests in a very entertaining way,

I guess the exception to all this would be the current crop of doom & gloom fragile folkies, who’s lyrics would indicate that they find it difficult to walk out their own front door, let alone walk on stage. This new sincerity thing is making for some excruciating moments. Speaking of which, anyone who witnessed the stunning slo-mo carcrash performance of The Brian Jones Town Massacre’s lead singer’s on stage Melbourne meltdown that was one long stream of conciousness rant inerspersed with the occassional song fragment, would attest that too much talking is more than enough.

What drags a lot of us away from our home stereo & the money out of our wallets & into the live music venues is the human factor, a curiosity & fascination with the person or people behind the work that we’ve come to love & intimately know, the desire to watch & hear the creator creating their creation. It’s a special kind of magic. And by being there we are part of the process, witnessing a series of once only moments that will perhaps never be repeated again, that it’s different because we are there. If it were just the music we could almost make do with the CD or DVD, but it’s not, it’s a lot more than just the music, there’s a yearning to commune, to mesh with the moment & it is a bit of a jolt to suddenly have an awkward silence, a self concious snigger, an embarassed shuffle or eyes averted mumbled “thanks” as the punctuation between works of such eloquence, style & & dignity. An actor doesn’t relax & scratch his arse on stage just because they’re not talking. The art continues.

Don’t get me wrong, I’m not advocating lounge lizard style nightclub schtick but simply the awareness that it’s SHOW business & the more you give the more that you get back.


 

 



 

back to top

 

THE SKULLCAVE FORUM